Report on
Discussion Forum on Information Services in the Asia-Pacific
and
AGRIS/CARIS in the 21st Century
an Asia-Pacific Regional Consultation

Edited by Michael Ibach and Yvonne Byron

DISCUSSION FORUM ON INFORMATION SERVICES

IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC

Becky Skidmore

ASEAN Forest Tree Seed Centre Project, Ottawa, Canada

[Back to OccPaper Top Page]

List of Acronyms

[Chapter 1]
Introduction

[Chapter 2]
Forestry Information Initiatives

[Chapter 3]
Collaboration

[Chapter 4]
The Survey

[Chapter 5]
The Discussion Forum

[Chapter 6]
Final Action Plans

[Chapter 7]
Keynote Papers

[Chapter 8]
Conclusions

[References]

[Appendix 1]
Survey Questionnaire

[Appendix 2]
Forestry Information Services in the Asia-Pacific Region

[Appendix 3]
The Future for Scientific Publishing and Information in the Asia-Pacific Region

[Appendix 4]
Information Services at IUFRO

[Appendix 5]
Sources of Forestry Information

[Appendix 6]
List of Participants

APPENDIX 1

SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE

 

Part A - Organisation and Management

1. Name (please underline family name): _____________________________________________________________

Position: ______________________________________________________________________________________

2. How many professional staff are employed in your institution?

3. What percentage of your institution's budget is allocated for information related activities?

a) _____ % b) no fixed amount c) do not know

4. In your organisational structure, the library/information services unit (ISU) is located:

a) under the administration division

b) under a specific research programme/division

c) as an independent unit at the same level as research divisions

d) other (please specify): ____________________________________________________________________

5. Do you have trained librarians/documentalists/information professionals in your institution?

a) yes ; how many: ________ b) no

If no, do you have future plans to train staff in these services: ___________________

6. Given limited budget, how would you prioritise the following (on a scale of 1 to 5; 1 indicates maximum and 5 minimum priority)?

 Priority
 a) Upgrading library and documentation centre  ______
 b) Purchasing computers/printers for scientists  ______
 c) Purchasing laboratory equipment  ______
 d) Increasing travel budgets for professional staff  ______
 e) Improving office quality  ______

7. In your institution, are literature reviews or problem analyses required in study plans or research proposal?

a) no b) yes

8. What do you consider to be the main impediments to completing high quality literature reviews or problem analyses?

 a) Lack of search capabalities  d) Lack of writing skills
 b) Lack of synthesising skills/experience e) Insufficient time
 c) Language difficulties  f) Other (please specify): ________________

9. Is your agency able to compete for international research funds? a) no b) yes

10. To what do you attribute your success (or failure)?

 a) Lack of contacts  e) Lack of proposal writing skills
 b) Poor research infrastructure  f) Language difficulties
 c) Lack of prior high quality output  g) Lack of guidelines or proposal format
 d) Lack of literature search facilities

11. How do the salaries of personnel in the following categories compare in your institution (on scale 1-4; 1 maximum)?

 Rank
 a) Professors/Senior professional staff  ____
 b) Senior Librarians  ____
 c) Senior Administrators  ____
 d) Senior Support Staff  ____

12. Are you familiar with CD-ROM technology and other advances in the information technology?

a) Yes, I keep abreast with the latest technology

b) No, I would like to but do not have enough time

c) I leave it to my information staff to keep me informed

d) I cannot because we do not have the necessary literature

e) Other reasons (please specify): ______________________________________________________________

13. How do researchers/managers in your institution share the research results?

 a) Weekly seminars  e) Published reports
 b) Monthly seminars  f) Publish in refereed journals
 c) Informal discussion  g) On need basis only
 d) Informal papers/working papers/newsletter  h) Others (please specify) ______________________

What are the major constraints? _______________________________________________________________

14. In your opinion do researchers/managers in your institution have access to relevant published literature?

a) No scientist has complained, so I presume we do

b) I am sure we have access to the required literature

c) I am sure we do not have access to the needed literature

d) We do not, but we can get it, if required

15. Is lack of adequate information perceived to be a constraint in improving the quality and quantity of research output from the institution?

a) Yes, certainly b) Partly c) No d) I am not sure

16. What are your greatest constraints in improving the research output of the institution (multiple answers are possible)?

 a) Lack of financial resources  c) Lack of equipment
 b) Lack of trained staff  d) Lack of political support
 e) Others (please specify) __________________________________________________________________

17. Does your institution have an existing research information management systems?

a) We do not have a research information management system

b) Yes, it is a part of the overall management information system

c) It exists on paper, but it is not operational

d) We are planning to set up a system

e) We are managing very well and I do not think there is a need for such a system

18. What, in your opinion, is the foremost reason for researchers/managers not using the existing and available informa- tion in your institution (multiple answers are possible)?

a) Not applicable, the researchers are using all available information in their work

b) Lack of suitable incentives

c) Lack of training to use information

d) Lack of motivation

e) Any other (please specify) _________________________________________________________________

19. The available information at your institutions is used to (multiple answers possible):

a) Writing research papers

b) Writing subject review papers

c) Preparing teaching materials

d) Writing project proposals

e) Creating in-house databases

20. Which is your preferred format for receiving research related information (multiple answers are possible)?

a) Computer diskettes b) CD-ROM c) Transmission over the internet d) Printed

21. In the above formats, do you find (multiple answers possible):

a) Databases containing only comprehensive abstracts of published literature to be very helpful and time saving

b) Products under a) are helpful but we have problems in obtaining original documents

c) I will prefer to have full text or abstracts are fine for use by researchers

d) Either full text or abstracts are fine for use by researchers

e) Cost would be the determining factor

 

Part B - Information Services

1. Name (please underline family name): _____________________________________________________________

Position: _________________________________________________________________________________________

2. Do you have a professional education in library science or related information services?

a) no b) yes , in ________________________________________________ with _____ years experience

3. How many people are employed in your library/Information Services Unit (ISU)? __________________________

4. Which facilities are available in your ISU (multiple answer possible)?

 a) Personal Computer  d) Photocopier  g) Full access to Internet
 b) Local Area Network  e) E-mail
 c) CD-ROM drive  f) Access to external on-line services

5. What is the estimated number of books/monographs in your library?

 a) < 500  c) 3,001 - 5,000  e) 10,001 - 15,000
 b) 500 - 3,000  d) 5,001 - 10,000  f) > 15,000

6. To how many journals (excluding newsletters) does your library currently subscribe?

a) < 5 d) 21 - 30 g) >50
b) 5 - 10 e) 31 - 40
c) 11 - 20 f) 41 - 50

Does this include any eletronically published journals? no yes , how many? ______

7. Do you subscribe to abstracting and indexing services (e.g. AGRIS, Current Contents)?

a) no b) yes , to ______________________________________________________________________________

8. Do you maintain statistics about the number of visitors or loans in your library?

a) no b) yes (please specify type and results): _____________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________

9. Who decides the purchase of new books/journals for use in the institution (multiple answers possible)?

 a) Director General and Director of Research  d) Library committee
 b) Requests from Researchers/Scientists/Managers  e) No fixed criterion
 c) Librarian suggests purchases   f) Other (please specify): __________________________

10. Do you provide a document delivery/photocopy service for documents available in your library?

no yes if yes, do you charge for it? no yes

11. Do you subscribe to an external document delivery service (e.g. British Library)?

no yes please specify: ________________________________________________________________________

12. Do you have arrangements for inter-library loans ? no yes , please specify policies and procedures :

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

13. Are you member of a network of partner organisations in the area of information services (e.g. CARIS, AGRIS, IILP, etc.)? no yes , please specify :

______________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________

14. Are there existing or planned networks you would like to subscribe to? no yes , please specify

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

15. Would you be interested in getting actively involved in new networks? no yes , please specify details of your interest:

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

16. Does your organisation have regular publications?

a) no b) yes , please specify (titles, formats, etc.): __________________________________________________

__________________________________________________

17. Do you have access to external databases?

no yes , please specify:_________________________________

____________________________________________________

18. Please describe databases developed and maintained in the ISU.

 Name Approx. No. of records  Language  Updating Period (months)
 <1  1-6  6-12  >12
 Available in electronic format
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 

19. Please describe databases maintained in other research programmes in your institute:

 Name Approx. No. of records  Language  Updating Period (months)
 <1  1-6  6-12  >12
 Available in electronic format
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 
   
     
 

20. What database management/library management software do you use, if any?

______________________________________________________________________

21. Please list five strengths of your institution as related to information access, information processing and information dissemination:

 a) _______________________________  d) _______________________________
 b) _______________________________  e) _______________________________
 c) _______________________________

22. Please list five constraints in achieving your objectives in the above areas.

 a) _______________________________  d) _______________________________
 b) _______________________________  e) _______________________________
 c) _______________________________

23. Would you be interested in a discussion forum on information services?

a) no b) yes , please specify (multiple answers possible):

 Type:  Geographic focus:
 a) conference  a) national
 b) workshop/seminar  b) regional
 c) informal meeting(s)  c) global
 d) electronic discussion group
 Involvement:  Costs for participation:
 a) present a paper  a) participate at own cost
 b) participate in forum organisation  b) can meet parts of the cost
 c) attend forum  c) depend fully on external funding
 d) be an active member